Bills and expenses after closing the contract
Sometimes, the deposit is retained with the excuse of unexpected expenses, like cleaning, wall painting, pending bills or similar.
The Italian law specifies that expenses cannot be withheld from the rent deposit, as such amount is meant to protect the landlord from financial losses or damages. Common expenses need to be paid separately by the tenant, unless differently agreed upon key return.
The deposit cannot be withheld pending the arrival of the utility bills.
Wall painting: Italian contracts often include the tenant's obligation to paint the wall upon leaving. This clause needs to be explicit in the rent contract, and cannot be present in short term contracts (less than 4 years). This is enforceable, and if not done the landlord can claim the damage. But the landlord needs to prove the expense with a receipt.
Example: Your landlord claims €500 for painting walls but doesn't provide a receipt. According to Italian law, you can claim your deposit back until the expense is proven
Utility bills: They cannot be withdrawn by the deposit unless the tenant agrees, and the landlord has no right to withhold the deposit until the bills arrive. Either the parties agree on a lump sum, or the tenant will reimburse the landlord of the faced costs
Cleaning: The landlord cannot force the tenant to hire a specialized cleaning firm, and they cannot withdraw the costs from the deposit unless they demonstrate that the flat was not left in the same conditions that the tenant has received it and justify the costs
Impossibility to contact the landlord
Sometimes, the landlord just exploits the geographical distance and disappears. It does not answer phone calls, messages and emails and limits any possible communication contacts.
This behaviour suggests that you are facing a rent fraud.
If the landlord is unreachable after the end of the rental contract, this does not exempt them from their obligation to return the deposit or to account for any legitimate deductions. You still have the full right to get back your deposit, and the landlord’s unresponsiveness can be interpreted as bad faith and strengthen the tenant’s position in legal proceedings.
You can still get the landlord to comply by formal means, without being physically close, for instance sending a Formal Notice: The tenant should send a formal letter of demand (diffida) via registered mail with return receipt (raccomandata con ricevuta di ritorno) or certified email (PEC) to the landlord's last known address, requesting the return of the deposit and setting a clear deadline (e.g., 10-15 days).
If it does not react, the tenant can escalate the matter and easily get back your money with expenses and damages. They can file a claim with the Justice of the Peace (Giudice di Pace) or seek a decreto ingiuntivo (injunction) through the court to recover the deposit. Legal assistance, though not mandatory, can expedite the process.
The tenant retains the right to recover the deposit and should document all attempts to contact the landlord, as this will serve as evidence if legal action becomes necessary.